The Challenge Test, also known as the Preservative Efficacy Test, is a mandatory microbiological safety requirement for most cosmetic products that contain water. Water-based formulations carry a higher risk of microbial contamination during storage and consumer use.
However, not all cosmetic products require this test. Products that are inherently resistant to microbial growth may qualify for a Challenge Test Exemption. Regulators classify these products as microbiologically low risk due to their formulation characteristics or packaging design.
A Challenge Test Exemption confirms that the product remains microbiologically safe without the need for preservatives or preservative efficacy testing.
Regulatory Basis: ISO 29621
The scientific and regulatory framework for Challenge Test Exemptions is defined in ISO 29621: Cosmetics — Microbiology — Guidelines for the risk assessment and identification of microbiologically low-risk products.
This international standard outlines how manufacturers can demonstrate that a cosmetic product does not support microbial survival or growth. The assessment focuses on formulation chemistry, water availability, pH, alcohol content, and packaging protection.
ISO 29621 provides the documented justification required for regulators and safety assessors to accept the exemption.
Formulation Characteristics That Define Low-Risk Products
The most important factor in determining microbiological risk is the formulation itself. Products must actively prevent microbial growth through their physical or chemical properties.
Water activity (aw) plays a critical role. Water activity measures the amount of free water available for microorganisms. When the water activity is equal to or below 0.75, microorganisms cannot grow. Anhydrous products such as body oils, lip balms, pressed powders, and solid sticks typically meet this criterion.
Extreme pH levels also create hostile environments for microorganisms. Products with a pH of 3.0 or lower, or 10.0 or higher, rapidly destroy microbial cell structures and prevent survival.
High concentrations of certain ingredients provide additional protection. Products containing 20 percent or more alcohol, such as perfumes and tonics, are considered microbiologically stable. Raw materials with inherent antimicrobial properties, including strong oxidizing agents, also contribute to low-risk classification.
Packaging and Manufacturing Conditions Supporting Exemption
Packaging design can significantly reduce contamination risk during consumer use. Products that prevent air or finger contact with the formula are considered low risk.
Single-dose units, sealed capsules, and unit-dose sachets eliminate repeated exposure. Airless pump systems also restrict microbial ingress and support exemption claims.
Manufacturing processes may further justify exemption. Filling products at temperatures of 65°C or higher effectively destroys vegetative microorganisms. When combined with protective packaging, this thermal process supports microbiological safety without preservatives.
Documentation Requirements for Challenge Test Exemption
A Challenge Test Exemption must be supported by clear scientific documentation. Manufacturers must demonstrate that the product remains microbiologically safe throughout its shelf life under normal conditions of use.
The justification should align with ISO 29621 principles and include data on formulation composition, water activity, pH, alcohol content, packaging type, and manufacturing controls.
When properly documented, a Challenge Test Exemption eliminates the need for preservative efficacy testing while maintaining full regulatory compliance and consumer safety.
Need support preparing compliant cosmetic labels? Our specialists can guide you through EU labelling requirements. Get in touch!
